quote:

ORIGINAL: Brad H

And yet, he won 14 games with them in 2024.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Lars

quote:

ORIGINAL: Brad H

And yet, he won 14 games with them in 2024.

Yup. And totally shit the bed in a playoff game. 14 regular season games won doesn't mean shit without a SB trophy. MIN has plenty of regular season wins. The trophy case is empty. When they needed him to deliver to get us to the SB, he sucked.

You can try to put as much lipstick on that pig as you want and tell me how the new TEAM he is on this year has done (hell - they probs win the SB). But he choked on last year's team, and based on what OUR roster and cap would have looked like this year, highly unlikely he does better. YMMV.

Again, it's not Darnold hate. Given performance on our roster and the totality of that and cap considerations, I personally don't think it was reasonable to assume a better performance from him this year with fewer team resources. Not surprised he did well in SEA. I would have been shocked if he had done well in MIN. Both things can be true.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Mark Anderson

quote:

ORIGINAL: Brad H

quote:

ORIGINAL: Mark Anderson

quote:

ORIGINAL: Bill Johanesen

I'm not backtracking on last year's QB situation.

Darnold was a crapola QB not worth $20 million over two years. But absent having anyone else he could compete for a year. Fast forward he choked, and while months of therapy could maybe rewire that element of his brain, he was not worth resigning because at that point he was a proven choker. He wasn't worth $100 million or $1 million. Naturally the team decides such matters, but from a fan/armchair GM perspective it was not about to deferring to O'Connell.

Then the team was in a quagmire having the #10 overall pick and no QB. The pick almost had to be QB but was the pick high enough to get one of the so-called top QBs. There was a lot of debate who it might be, could we trade up even more, etc. All of them had pros and cons so it became a matter of hoping the one selected would pan out. After two years, I don't think JJM is the QBOTF. Some growing pians are expected. But his results were, by some measures, among the worst in the modern era. And while he may never have another injury, his track record says he simply has too many injuries.

I think we make the playoffs with Darnold. Maybe one win. Our OLine is just too soft and our DBs would get smoked by competent offenses

If you compare the 22 starters between Vikings and SEA, we maybe have 5 or 6 guys that would start.

And yet, he won 14 games with them in 2024.

Yes. He was one of the positions that went to the Seahawks. I would say JJ, O'Neill, Van Ginkel, Redmond and possibly Turner would start if you combined the 2 teams.

If you are being honest, the Rams made us look like a 5 win team in last year's playoff game. Very similar to the Giants playoff loss when Cousins won 13 games.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Phil Riewer

quote:

ORIGINAL: Mark Anderson

quote:

ORIGINAL: Brad H

quote:

ORIGINAL: Mark Anderson

quote:

ORIGINAL: Bill Johanesen

I'm not backtracking on last year's QB situation.

Darnold was a crapola QB not worth $20 million over two years. But absent having anyone else he could compete for a year. Fast forward he choked, and while months of therapy could maybe rewire that element of his brain, he was not worth resigning because at that point he was a proven choker. He wasn't worth $100 million or $1 million. Naturally the team decides such matters, but from a fan/armchair GM perspective it was not about to deferring to O'Connell.

Then the team was in a quagmire having the #10 overall pick and no QB. The pick almost had to be QB but was the pick high enough to get one of the so-called top QBs. There was a lot of debate who it might be, could we trade up even more, etc. All of them had pros and cons so it became a matter of hoping the one selected would pan out. After two years, I don't think JJM is the QBOTF. Some growing pians are expected. But his results were, by some measures, among the worst in the modern era. And while he may never have another injury, his track record says he simply has too many injuries.

I think we make the playoffs with Darnold. Maybe one win. Our OLine is just too soft and our DBs would get smoked by competent offenses

If you compare the 22 starters between Vikings and SEA, we maybe have 5 or 6 guys that would start.

And yet, he won 14 games with them in 2024.

Yes. He was one of the positions that went to the Seahawks. I would say JJ, O'Neill, Van Ginkel, Redmond and possibly Turner would start if you combined the 2 teams.

If you are being honest, the Rams made us look like a 5 win team in last year's playoff game. Very similar to the Giants playoff loss when Cousins won 13 games.

Why did they win 14 games? Easier Schedule.
Same reason the Bears won the divison this year.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Trekgeekscott

quote:

ORIGINAL: Phil Riewer

quote:

ORIGINAL: Mark Anderson

quote:

ORIGINAL: Brad H

quote:

ORIGINAL: Mark Anderson

quote:

ORIGINAL: Bill Johanesen

I'm not backtracking on last year's QB situation.

Darnold was a crapola QB not worth $20 million over two years. But absent having anyone else he could compete for a year. Fast forward he choked, and while months of therapy could maybe rewire that element of his brain, he was not worth resigning because at that point he was a proven choker. He wasn't worth $100 million or $1 million. Naturally the team decides such matters, but from a fan/armchair GM perspective it was not about to deferring to O'Connell.

Then the team was in a quagmire having the #10 overall pick and no QB. The pick almost had to be QB but was the pick high enough to get one of the so-called top QBs. There was a lot of debate who it might be, could we trade up even more, etc. All of them had pros and cons so it became a matter of hoping the one selected would pan out. After two years, I don't think JJM is the QBOTF. Some growing pians are expected. But his results were, by some measures, among the worst in the modern era. And while he may never have another injury, his track record says he simply has too many injuries.

I think we make the playoffs with Darnold. Maybe one win. Our OLine is just too soft and our DBs would get smoked by competent offenses

If you compare the 22 starters between Vikings and SEA, we maybe have 5 or 6 guys that would start.

And yet, he won 14 games with them in 2024.

Yes. He was one of the positions that went to the Seahawks. I would say JJ, O'Neill, Van Ginkel, Redmond and possibly Turner would start if you combined the 2 teams.

If you are being honest, the Rams made us look like a 5 win team in last year's playoff game. Very similar to the Giants playoff loss when Cousins won 13 games.

Why did they win 14 games? Easier Schedule.
Same reason the Bears won the divison this year.

I don't buy it

Do you know how many games the last place schedule actually effects? Not as many as you might think.

Only three games are determined by where you finished in your division.
Sure you might catch a weaker division (AFC South for example) but for the most part the difference between our schedule and the Packers will just be three games.

Also from one year to the next a weak team can become stronger through Free agency, trades and the draft. If it is done well...

So Schedule strength is a weak argument IMHO.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Chris Olson

OMG...

I sit here in wonder that I think I seriously would take Kirko Chainz back in a heart beat

it would be hysterical

somehow his agent would get us to pay him $100 mil for 2 yrs

quote:

ORIGINAL: twinsfan

Kwesi fired today. I guess they couldn't let the Twins have their own day. [X(]

quote:

ORIGINAL: David Levine

quote:

ORIGINAL: twinsfan

Kwesi fired today. I guess they couldn't let the Twins have their own day. [X(]

Nobody cares about the Twins.


Tom Pelissero:
Now official: Kwesi Adofo-Mensah is out as Vikings GM and longtime executive Rob Brzezinski will lead all operations through the 2026 NFL Draft.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Chris Olson

OMG...

I sit here in wonder that I think I seriously would take Kirko Chainz back in a heart beat

it would be hysterical

somehow his agent would get us to pay him $100 mil for 2 yrs

quote:

ORIGINAL: fmaltes

https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/47779886/vikings-fire-gm-kwesi-adofo-mensah-4-seasons

Kwesi fired. I was still surprised, but as was very clearly documented on this site, his drafting record is horrible and has really set back the organization. Also, his free agency signings record was mixed too. I am curious how they will handle the draft and if they really wait to get a new GM after the draft.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Trekgeekscott

quote:

ORIGINAL: Chris Olson

OMG...

I sit here in wonder that I think I seriously would take Kirko Chainz back in a heart beat

it would be hysterical

somehow his agent would get us to pay him $100 mil for 2 yrs

It's a distinct possibility nobody is talking about. Altanta and KC reworked his deal to lessen the cap hit if they release him....With the intent of letting him go when then new league year starts as a June 1 designation. There he would be, a guy that knows KOCs system, who has had success with it, even though many of us here would probably lose our shit if they did bring him back.

Kwesi was fired today...perhaps he suggested a KC KOC reunion and the Wilfs said, **** you your fired.

quote:

ORIGINAL: TJSweens

I just hope they made Queasy take his draft pick trade value chart with him.