Trekgeekscott -> RE: MLB General Information PT 4 (1/30/2014 11:56:14 AM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: CPAMAN quote:
ORIGINAL: twinsfan If Larry Walker isn't in, it's hard to argue that Berkman should be. hmmm, this group of players falls into what I call the Joe Mauer conundrum. Players that put up good numbers during their careers, however, playoff games, World Series appearances, and certain other intangibles just seem to be missing to put them into Cooperstown. I realize some people consider Mauer a first ballot HOF guy. [&o] IMO, he presently falls short of HOF status. If he could put together another solid five seasons and perhaps add another batting title to his resume, even I would probably give him consideration. But the Larry Walkers, Lance Berkmans and even the Chris Biggios of MLB are marginal HOF players IMO. Well, at least not first ballot HOF players. [;)] Except Mauer has performed well in the Postseason. and by the time his career is truly over, he will have career numbers that clearly justify his inclusion in the HOF. First Ballot? that remains to be seen. but he's certainly on the right path.
|
|
|
|