CPAMAN -> RE: MLB General Information PT 4 (1/10/2014 4:47:17 PM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Dave E quote:
ORIGINAL: twinsfan quote:
ORIGINAL: Dave E quote:
ORIGINAL: ewen21 quote:
ORIGINAL: CPAMAN And how exactly does Len justify his privilege to vote by casting a vote for Jacque Jones? Please explain this to me. LeVelle of all people should talk. I'm no Pedro Martinez fan, but if you recall he left Martinez off the MVP ballot (along with a NY sportswriter) just to make a point. Before he speaks out on this debacle he needs to ask himself...is this really any different than what he did? I'm not so sure it is I almost pity him, making a fool of himself like this. There are guys with votes who cover golf, for crying out loud. And guys like Barreiro have votes, and his only connection to baseball these days is 1) pleading for Black Jack Morris and 2) bitching about Joe Mauer. The fact that Barreiro has a vote is ridiculous. Do you really think he's doing his due diligence in checking out out the credentials for each candidate? He won't even let his listeners know who he voted for (other than, I assume, Black Jack Morris). He's not even a sportswriter anymore, and hasn't been one for 10 years. He barely keeps up with the Twins, much less baseball. How he is more qualified to vote on the HOF than anyone on this board is beyond me. IMO, HOF voting should be drawn to the mean for "qualified and authenticated votes". What I saying is that votes casts for obscure players like Jacques Jones by one sportswriter should be entirely ignored. Similarly, if 70% of the voters voted for a guy like Craig Biggio, or let's call it 74.8%, and the same voters did not vote for players like Maddux, Glavine and Thomas who were voted in by the majority, then their entire ballot should be tossed out. What this method would do is ignore the extremists votes. It would be similar to eliminating votes from extreme liberals to extreme conservatives in a political election. Get the majority opinion rather than allowing a few imbeciles to impact the decision-making.
|
|
|
|