Tom Sykes
Posts: 5872
Joined: 7/27/2007
Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: David Levine quote:
ORIGINAL: bohumm quote:
ORIGINAL: Phil Riewer quote:
ORIGINAL: bohumm quote:
ORIGINAL: Phil Riewer It isn't time to blow up the team...it is time to change coaches though. I would keep Spielman....just look at the mid to late round talent playing at RB and WR. If it was up to me I would go after Jim Caldwell, Doug Pederson, or Bienemy. Who hired Zimmer? Who extended Kirk in competition with no one? Who extended Barr, Rudy, Smith with high guarantees at the tail end of their careers? Who overpays the wrong positions (RB, S, LB) while having the worst IOL in the league? Spielman isn't horrible, but he's not that good either. Every team finds guys. How many get nothing out of the first round for years in a row, ending only when JJ falls into his lap? Spielman has to go with the rest. The Wilfs need to break from their middling start of ownership by adapting to the way the league is now, not continuing with 1950s Era football. Zimmer guys were extended...Smith, Barr, Kendricks, Hunter, Rhodes...Rudolph, Thielen, and Cousins I would put on Spielman but look what 15 million gave back....Tomlinson, Vigil, Cole, Richardson, and Patrick Peterson...where would we have been this year w/o them? You keep ignoring the fact that Spielman is in charge of the football operations, so he is responsible for all signings. He is also responsible for hiring Zimmer, so assigning blame to Zimmer for personnel moves is doubly ludicrous. Finally, the "season savers" you cite top out at OK for their performances this year so far. Literally every team has a version of "Tomlinson, Vigil, Cole, Richardson, and Patrick Peterson". I don't want budget shopping or quantity of 7th round picks amassed to be the calling card of my GM. Good post. Add 'screwing the cap with outrageous extensions' and you hit the trifecta of the Spielman era. I give Spielman credit for trying to plug holes with slightly better than scrap heap level veterans (mostly) AND no cap ... but he is directly responsible for the cap crises to begin with, so ...
|