kgdabom
Posts: 33770
Joined: 7/29/2007
Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: bstinger
quote:
ORIGINAL: Bill Johanesen
quote:
ORIGINAL: bstinger
quote:
ORIGINAL: Bill Johanesen
quote:
ORIGINAL: bstinger
quote:
ORIGINAL: Bill Johanesen
quote:
ORIGINAL: bstinger
quote:
ORIGINAL: Bill Johanesen
Every year this comes up.
There could be 20 compensatory picks in a round and we trade into the last one. Come hell or highwater, by god we stayed in the round even though value wise we ended up with the 20th pick in the NEXT round.
What matters is how many slots you move, the round is pretty much irrelevant when the comp picks start. However, the NFL calls it the 3rd, so it's the 3rd.
It matters when teams are using value charts, which they do. Unlike you, they likely factor in adjusting them especially as the pool of comp picks become an ever larger factor as the rounds go on. It's stuff over your head.
KMA
Yep, you have nothing. Just don't trying assigning value to any trade from the 3rd round on and you'll be ok.
Not sure what you're getting at. Every pick has a value, the round is irrelevant. That being said, it doesn't appear that Queasy got good value here.
He gave up a pick worth 155 and received 92+24.6+1.1= 117.7
https://www.drafttek.com/NFL-Trade-Value-Chart.asp
Right, I don't get trade chart value, right... Like I said before the round doesn't matter as much as the # of spots you move, but it's still the 3rd round.
Don't know how simple I can make it: value wise, like when you access a value chart w/o comp picks to see the points on a trade, you'd have to look at the 7th spot in the 4th to see how much it's worth.
By not doing that, every pick does NOT have a value. The comp picks have to be factored in. Everything slips backwards.
The chart you reference, which I use and have posted here twice the last couple of days, does factor the comp picks in. Many don't. If they don't it's a 4th, point wise.
I don't know how simple I can make it. The round doesn't matter in the value it's the # of slots between picks. However when talking about which round a pick is in, I will defer to the terminology used by the GD league that runs the draft, not your interpretation of what you think it should be.
100% agreement. So now you probably need to change your mind since I agree with you.
_____________________________
"So let it be written.
So let it be done."
|
Printable Version
RE: 2023 NFL Draft - 
New Messages
No New Messages
Hot Topic w/ New Messages
Hot Topic w/o New Messages
Locked w/ New Messages
Locked w/o New Messages
Post New Thread