Brad H
Posts: 22986
Joined: 8/16/2007
From: Parts Unknown
Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Steve Lentz Creg Stephenson | cstephenson@al.com Email the author | Follow on Twitter on December 27, 2016 at 9:45 AM, updated December 27, 2016 at 9:48 AM The website FiveThirtyEight.com recently ranked college football teams from the past 80 years by something called ELO score, which was originally created to rank chess players (and the formula for which I can't begin to understand). The ELO system (not affiliated with Electric Light Orchestra as far as I know) has also been used on a year-to-year basis by college football computer whiz Jeff Sagarin. At any rate, the all-time ELO rankings have the current Alabama team at No. 1, just ahead of 1995 Nebraska and 2015 Alabama. Obviously, the Crimson Tide must win its final two games -- against Washington in the Peach Bowl and against either Clemson or Ohio State in the national championship game -- to stay atop those rankings. I do not have a mathematical formula to back me up on this, but I still consider the 1995 Nebraska team the greatest of my lifetime (1973-present), just ahead of 2016 Alabama. Here's why: * The Cornhuskers' closest win that year was by 14 points over Washington State, 35-21. In that game, the Cougars scored with 3 1/2 minutes left to cut it to 14. In every other game, Nebraska won by at least 23. By contrast, Alabama has had a couple of close calls, with a 48-43 victory over Ole Miss and a 10-0 win over LSU on its schedule. In the earlier game, the Crimson Tide actually led by 18 in the second half before the Rebels scored two late touchdowns, but the LSU game was scoreless heading into the final quarter. * Hold on, you say, Nebraska probably beat up on a weak Big 8 conference that year. Well, not really. Kansas State, Colorado and Kansas all finished with at least 10 wins, and the Cornhuskers whipped them all by an average score of 45-16. Alabama has one victory so far over a team with double-digit wins, that being a 38-10 win over a Western Kentucky team that finished 11-3. USC, which Alabama beat 52-6 on opening weekend, is the only other Crimson Tide regular-season opponent with a chance to get to 10 wins. (And let's remember teams play one more regular-season game now than they did back then, which they played just 11). * Nebraska won its national championship by routing Florida 62-24 in the Fiesta Bowl. That Gators team, which many (including me) considered the best of the Steve Spurrier era, had won all its previous games by double-digits. Alabama won't have a chance to beat a team as good as that 1995 Florida team. Alabama's championship story is not yet written. Should the Crimson Tide win convincingly over Washington and Ohio State/Clemson, then I would say it certainly has an argument as the greatest team of all-time. For one thing, the Crimson Tide would have played 15 games whereas Nebraska in 1995 played only 12. That's 25 percent more games -- and thus, three more chances to lose -- for one team over the other. And Nebraska in 1995 did not have to play a conference championship game, nor did it have to win a national semifinal game. If Alabama wins out, it will have beaten the country's No. 4 team and then either No. 2 or No. 3. So here's the bottom line -- If Alabama wins its next two games in convincing fashion, it's the greatest college football team of all time in my opinion. But it's not there yet. (As an aside, we all remember in 2005 when ESPN was hyping USC as the greatest college football team of all time. The Trojans then promptly lost in the Rose Bowl to Vince Young and Texas, in what might be the most exciting college football game ever). So what do you think? Any other teams you'd consider for No. 1 all-time? I'll take your questions and comments on that or anything else on your mind beginning at 10 a.m. I would agree with you that the '95 Nebraska team was better than this Bama team. However, I'll take the 2004 USC team over either of them.
_____________________________
Defense starts at the corners!
|