Guest
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Bill Jandro At this point in their careers it is simply not possible to compare Luck vs Wilson due to the teams they play on. Wilson simply does not have to carry his team and can punt w/o worrying. Luck has no defense or running game and simply has to carry his team on his shoulders. If, and when these qb's supporting casts become more similar any comparison will have too many holes in it. That's a decades old debate Bill. Was Terry Bradshaw a great QB, or was the team around him just so overwhelmingly good that it propped him up? Was Troy Aikman that good, when Dan Marino was obviously more dynamic as a passer? Andrew Luck is the prototypical QB that NFL GM's have wet dreams over, both physically, and mentally. Perhaps his team hasn't grown to his level around him yet? Luck is an incredible talent, and he will be great for years. However Russell Wilson has had to make all the critical plays in his couple seasons that have propelled the Seahawks to heights a once downtrodden franchise has never been. Just listen to the freakin guy talk, he's two steps ahead in his mind, and is a superior talent in his own right.... I like both Luck, and Wilson.....
_____________________________
I am collecting for the Leukemia and Lymphoma Society in memory of my fiance who passed away on 9/9/2006. If anyone would like to donate just go to http://pages.lightthenight.org/mn/TwinCiti09/SMiller Any and all donations will be greatly appreciated.
|