jbusse
Posts: 1309
Joined: 9/11/2013
From: Atlanta, GA
Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: David F. quote:
ORIGINAL: Ricky J quote:
ORIGINAL: Tom Sykes quote:
ORIGINAL: David F. quote:
ORIGINAL: marty I still wouldn't trust Carlson for a game winner in a playoff game, despite his regular season success. I am not sure if Zimmer ruins kickers, or if he doesn't convey confidence, or whatever it is winning HCs convey to their kickers. Blair Walsh was all pro. Dan Bailey was the most accurate kicker in history. Carlson missed three of four FGs for us in the TWO GAMES we kept him (he was one of only two drafted kickers that year - the other was Jason Sanders). Since we cut him he's missed 12 total out of 92. That's 87% including being 7 of 11 from 50+. Based on post game comments about Joseph, Zimmer seems committed to being more positive or at least, giving a longer leash to the kicker this year. An acknowledgement probably of his past meddling. Of course, its a catch-22 right? Drop the axe too soon and you might be rejecting a Carlson ... hang on too long and your Walsh has more opportunities to not get it right. I think Spielman and Zimmer have tried different things but, at this point, I'm not sure they can get out of their own way ... even when they just stand and watch and do nothing. I've noticed that even prior to this last hiccup as well. This one didn't cost them the game, though, so maybe it made swallowing the pill a little easier. We just can't expect our kickers to be 100%. When Green Bay played Cincinnati Mason Crosby missed THREE field goals - and Green Bay still won. The offenses job isn't over once we're in field goal range and the kick should never be taken for granted. This isn't a knock on Cousins (who has been mostly excellent this season) but more a knock on the coaches and fans - driving the team into field goal range DOES NOT constitute a game-winning drive. It's only a game-winning-drive if the kicker makes it. If you don't want to take an 80% chance on a win then scheme for a TD. Blaming your kicker for losses is a coward's way out. That's right, and it's why in these close-game situations the analytics call for more aggressive play calling even after the team is in field goal range. Zimmer seems to not trust Cousins enough (e.g., worry too much about a pick or an incomplete pass that stops the clock) and trust his defense too much. It's like he's still coaching the 2017 team, when the defense was much better (until the playoffs, that is), and Keenum had the tendency to make an ill advised pass every once in a while.
|