Mark Anderson
Posts: 12093
Joined: 9/1/2007
Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Brad H quote:
ORIGINAL: JT2 quote:
ORIGINAL: Richard Neussendorfer quote:
ORIGINAL: JT2 quote:
ORIGINAL: Mark Anderson quote:
ORIGINAL: Jeff Jesser No need to move up that far. Agree. Not "my list" but the general consensus is that these are the guys that can go in the first: Williams May Nix Penix McCarthy Ewers Daniels I don't think Sanders is coming out so left him off. Haven't seen much of Daniels to comment but he has great stats. Everyone else, I've watched a good bit of. I would say hell no to Nix, Ewers and McCarthy for various reasons. Penix is my favorite guy but the injury history scares me a bit. Williams Maye Daniels McCarthy Nix Penix Ewers That's my order right now. I've see Penix a few times lately. Not sure about the side arm delivery. McCarthy has a cannon. Underrated because Michigan doesn't pass much. McCarthy is underrated. His progression over the last two years is pretty remarkable. He's very athletic and fast, and he's Pro-ready. Best QB in the nation on play action, and arguably the best passer in the nation outside of the pocket. His size could be an issue in the NFL. He's on the short side of 6'3" I wouldn't be shocked though if he decided to stay in Ann Arbor. McCarthy last 4 games he's averaging 124 yards passing and has a grand total of 1 td pass. I say no thanks. Don't be fooled. Michigan has given up a handful of TD's the entire season. They play from the lead and run it down your throat. No need to sling it. I'm saying don't let the box scores fool you, McCarthy is the real deal. If he comes out, I wouldn't be surprised if he has the best NFL career of this QB draft class. On the other hand, Caleb Williams has averaged 322 yards passing per game over the last five. They won one of those games. Do you think McCarthy should pass more to pad his stats, or just lead his team to continuous victories? Given that it's a passing league, I'll take the guy that plays in a passing offense. I like McCarthy, but I'd take any one of 3-4 guys in the Pac 12 over him. If McCarthy played in Pac12, his numbers would be of the video game variety.
|