Phil Riewer
Posts: 27426
Joined: 8/24/2007
From: MN
Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Tom Sykes quote:
ORIGINAL: Phil Riewer quote:
ORIGINAL: Tom Sykes quote:
ORIGINAL: ratoppenheimer quote:
ORIGINAL: Phil Riewer quote:
ORIGINAL: ratoppenheimer quote:
ORIGINAL: Jeff Jesser So, curious what ya'll would do. Listened to a Purple Daily podcast that talked about something I've thought of recently. Lets say you evaluate this years QB's and you think Daniels/May (whoever falls to 3) is a franchise QB. Would you be willing to trade JJ, and whatever picks to get to #3? You still have the 11 and roll the dice on the franchise QB roulette wheel. You could even take a stud WR at 11 to replace him. BTW - this is not bringing KC's back. You would have: #3 - hopefully franchise guy on rookie salary #11 - possible stud WR on rookie deal with Addison in place for cheap or a really good/stud D filler at interior/edge/CB more picks to fill the D holes more cap room to round out the D As much as I love JJ, I think i'd do it. i'd try to trade up and take harrison jr, too...then you'd really have something to build on.... I would have zero issues trading away JJ and grabbing Harrison JR and then grabbing QB at 11. In the scenario above, the decision could be; 1. Top three qb and the third wr taken (not Harrison), or 2. Harrison jr and penix - McCarthy - nix - rattler…. Option 2? If you are not trading up for a qb you sure as hell aren’t trading up for a wr. If Kwevin decides to resign Cousins for 3-4 years and shoot holes through our cap that way (instead of JJ) … which I wouldnt put past them … And only if the big three QBs were out of play. OK then … Trade JJ for Marvin Jr and help the roster with the difference in salary. That fantasy makes no sense to me either actually. Skin a cat any way you want. Trade JJ for a QB and draft an edge or cb at 11. Just get high end talent.....Harrison Jr. doesn't seem like a bad option but there are other WR available later. Yes. We have something better than Harrison ... most likely a lot better. Filthy more expensive, yes, but the chances of Harrison being in the top 3 at his position are just okay. Top 10 - pretty good, eventually. True JJ's a special talent and therefore an outside the box conversation ... But just the fact that we're talking about gambling on one cornerstone WR vs a cheaper possible cornerstone WR is ... silly IMO. QB and how to get one. Period. Then Edge, CB, LT. Even if we trade up using JJ to a get a QB and package it in a way to keep #11, which can't happen in the real world but if it did, we would have to go Edge or CB at #11. WR would be a 3rd (which we don't have right now) or 4th rd consideration after OL and DL. Who knows what picks we would have after moving up. Then after the draft how to extend Darrisaw. Our dike has been tsunami'ed by Spielman and Kwevin. JJ or Harrison is barely just one little sandbag to consider. I actually disagree...the offense side will be good next year; the dike is on the defense but add a few thru draft and FA and Flores will have it at top 12 again....
_____________________________
SSG Riewer, Greg A Co 2/136 CAB KIA 23 March 2007 Habbaniyah Iraq
|