Bill Jandro
Posts: 17929
Joined: 8/13/2007
Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: kgdabom quote:
ORIGINAL: Bill Jandro quote:
ORIGINAL: kgdabom quote:
ORIGINAL: Bill Jandro quote:
ORIGINAL: Tom Sykes quote:
ORIGINAL: unome quote:
ORIGINAL: Tom Sykes Our strategy has been, as Childress or more importantly Immortan Joe would say, "Mediocre"! Draft one player in the first 4 rds, make some wild stabs in the later rounds, pick up a middling vet or two, and allow Cousins start another prayer group. Beavers Elflein Isidora O'Neill Gossett Bradbury Samia Udoh Cleveland Brandel Hinton 'has' (not the plural 'have' because that is one big amorphous blob of OL talent) produced one good starter (so far) in O'Neill and below average overall OL play. Our last game was freakin' abysmal how could we not be panicking and selling out for OL help? Sure, hopefully Bradbury makes a big leap this year and is average or better, and Cleveland / one of the late round stabs will end up being more than just depth – but only a true homer thinks that's a given. After the volcanic free agency eruption of Reiff and Remmers in 2017, we have augmented our draft strategy with Josh Andrews, Tom Compton, Bryan Witzmann, Josh Kline, Brett Jones, Dakota Dozier. I wonder if Hall had passed his physical, if we still would have signed Ngakoue ... probably. Our 'dire' cap situation seems only to be dire in relation to helping the OL, not the rest of the team and especially not the defense. Great post,. I LOLed at the bolded. "Beavers Elflein Isidora O'Neill Gossett Bradbury Samia Udoh Cleveland Brandel Hinton". Going back further and you have the likes of Clemmings and Yankey as well. We have one excellent player from that list, a few who have already busted out and a bunch of question marks, We need to get 4 good-to-great starters from that list. There are three starters on the list, but only one has yet qualified under the "good-to-great' part. Thanks. I will grant you that the Spielman has drafted more and better OL in the last few years ... but the standard is low and our current situation is based on a lot of jacked-up hopefulness. Spielman as GM OL Summary 2012 - 2016 (first 5 years) Kalil Baca Bond Yankey Clemmings Thompson Shepherd Beavers The offensive line apocalypse of 2016 2017 -2020 (last four years) Elflein Isidora O'Neill Gossett Bradbury Samia Udoh Cleveland Brandel Hinton It's obvious Spielman and the scouts he has assembled have little to no clue how to evaluate olineman. I think O'Neil, Bradbury, Udoh and Cleveland will all be good players. So far 2 can't crack the starting line up and another one is only starting due to lofty draft status not performance. O'Neal is good-Blind squirrel nut theory. Spielman is good at certain things, assembling an oline isn't one of them. Wow a second year player and a rookie not starting and another 2nd year starter isn't a star yet. I stand by my comment. I think all of them will be good players. Bradbury was a very high pick. For him to be the worst starting C in the league last season is not a very promising sign. Not saying he can't/won't improve. I'm not throwing in the towel on Udoh or Clev and with the shortened camp it's somewhat understandable. But Dozier and Elf aren't good players. Both are at the bottom rung in pass pro so not beating either of these two out doesn't bode well. Then we have Spielman's past track record drafting olineman to consider. I'd list the 8 years of futility but I don't want anyone throwing up in their mouth this morning. I hope these players will be good. But the jury is still out and in no way shape or form can you say with any certainty their all going to be good. That's the purple goggles talking.
_____________________________
Oline...early and often this draft
|