Phil Riewer
Posts: 32507
Joined: 8/24/2007
From: MN
Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Trekgeekscott quote:
ORIGINAL: Phil Riewer quote:
ORIGINAL: beo quote:
ORIGINAL: Phil Riewer quote:
ORIGINAL: Trekgeekscott quote:
ORIGINAL: Phil Riewer quote:
ORIGINAL: Jeff Jesser Agree with all the bench Murray stuff...I never thought he would be this terrible.... I hope the hamstring is our way to a soft benching I really think Wentz is much more a KOC type QB The only thing that Murray brings, that Wentz doesn't, is he pretty good at protecting the ball. That said, it's been so anemic you have to live with Wentz's brain farts. After 1 loss you want to go with Wentz? Kyler drove us down and scored when needed and we didn't go for it on 4th and 5 after our Defense didn't stop Detroit the series before......I don't know if it still warrants the change. I think our RG is our biggest problem right now. I think Fries is affecting the running game and passing game. When Detroilet's defense lost FIVE starters to injury during this game, Kyler Murray was unable to take advantage. That to me is damning. When we needed a drive, Kyler Murray led this offense to a 3 and out. When Our defense needed a breather he went 3 and out. When it mattered MOST, Kyler Murray didn't get the job done. But the most damning part to me is JJ showing visible signs of frustration ON THE FIELD and ON THE SIDELINES. This team wen't 6-0 despite having Kyler Murray as a QB. We lost because Kyler Murray couldn't get the job done when needed. Kyler Murray Missed WIDE OPEN guys repeatedly, his passes sailed overthrown many times. This team could be nearly unstoppable with an effective ball control offense, one that keeps moving the chains and dominates time of possession. That keeps the defense well rested and gives them a lead to work with. Kyler Murray has demonstrated to me that he is NOT the answer and that we have an window here that is closing fast because we don't get competent QB play. Wentz is no savior. But he runs it better than Murray. I didn't come to this feeling just after losing one game. I felt this way three games ago. Wentz is the clearly the best QB we have on the roster right now. I may as well cheer for the other team if we are starting Wentz. We are doomed. If Wentz started against Detroit they would have blitzed continually up the middle like they did against Darnold the year before and Wentz has zero mobility. Fries/RG is the most serious problem right now. I'm not in love with Wentz either. But really? You don't think Wentz wins that game? Kyler did not use his mobility much in that game... in fact I'd say he moved in the pocket pretty poorly. I think Wentz wins that game pretty easily. Can he make any noise going forward... I don't know... history would say probably not. Such is Viking fandom. I don't. TOP would have been worse also as Kyler had a couple first downs and that is how Detroit beats you---TOP and at the end the defense hasn't very little left. I don't agree. Wentz likely throws to an open reciever and gets first downs and keeps drives going. I don't know how you think Kyler would be better here...I understand the mobility factor, but Wentz can see the open receiver and deliver the ball. I don't think you can determine who would have been better at TOP, but Wentz has run this offense better, which means more passes to open receivers delivered accurately. I personally believe THAT would have kept drives alive where Kuler's died and that would have won us this game. But that, is JMO They are basically the same type of games we see with Kyler except: 1) Less TOP. 2) More TOs 3) Less Mobility. If you choose Wentz for the rest of the year.....we have no shot in the playoffs. I don't see the defense holding up. Kyler still has the higher ceiling. I am hoping for a QB trade this week....just don't know which. I can't believe the Ravens traded for Brissett.
< Message edited by Phil Riewer -- 11/4/2026 2:26:16 PM >
_____________________________
SSG Riewer, Greg A Co 2/136 CAB KIA 23 March 2007 Habbaniyah Iraq
|